Comparison card: Catching Numbers works in your own accounting software, Bench runs on its own platform or QuickBooks Online

Bench is still in business: it shut down on December 27, 2024, was bought by Employer.com days later, and now sells bookkeeping from $199 a month on its own platform or from $399 a month inside QuickBooks Online. Catching Numbers also starts at $199 a month, always works in your own accounting software, and adds an accrual month-end close with CPA sign-off when you need it, on month-to-month terms. Bench fits owners who want bookkeeping and a business tax return from one provider. We fit businesses that want their books in their own file, closed and reviewed every month. We compared both using each firm’s own pricing page, checked November 18, 2026. We are one of the two firms compared.

Key takeaways

  • Bench Bookkeeping Light is $199 a month for businesses with $250,000 or less in annual revenue; Bench Bookkeeping is $399 a month.
  • Bench’s main plans run on its own platform. Its QuickBooks Online plans start at $399 a month for cash-basis books.
  • Bench sells business tax filing, from $649 a month bundled with bookkeeping. We don’t prepare returns and work alongside your tax CPA.
  • We work in QuickBooks Online, Xero, NetSuite, Sage Intacct and AI-native ledgers, so your books never depend on one provider’s platform.

What happened to Bench?

Bench told customers its platform would no longer be accessible as of December 27, 2024, and advised them to file tax extensions. Three days later, Employer.com, an HR and payroll company, agreed to buy Bench and said it would revive the platform and let customers either stay or take their data, as reported by TechCrunch. Bench now sells bookkeeping and tax plans again on its website.

The lesson for any business, whoever keeps its books: make sure the records live in software you control. When books sit inside a provider’s own platform, moving away means exporting what you can and rebuilding the rest.

How do Catching Numbers and Bench compare on price?

Catching NumbersBench
Entry price$199 a month: up to 2 accounts and 100 transactionsBookkeeping Light, $199 a month, for $250,000 or less in annual revenue
Main bookkeeping planQuoted on volume; early-stage companies typically $599 to $699 a monthBookkeeping, $399 a month on Bench’s platform
Inside QuickBooks OnlineEvery plan, and also Xero, NetSuite, Sage Intacct and others$399 a month (cash basis, up to 500 transactions), $699 (cash or accrual, up to 2,000) or from $999
Month-end close with controller review$2,440 to $3,750 a month, bookkeeping included, CPA sign-offNot listed as a plan
Catch-up$150, $300 or $600 per month behind, by volume; $499 minimumCurrent-year backlog free with an annual plan; older backlog quoted
Tax returnsNot offered; we hand your tax CPA a year-end packageBookkeeping + Tax, $649 a month; tax only, $300 a month
BillingMonth to monthMonthly, or annual at 20% off; monthly tax plans need a 12-month commitment
Prices from each firm’s own pricing page, checked November 18, 2026. Confirm the current price and scope in writing before you sign.

Sources: our pricing page and Bench’s pricing page.

Which costs less?

For very small books, the entry prices match at $199 a month. If you want bookkeeping and a business tax return from one provider, Bench’s $649 bundle is simpler to buy, since we don’t prepare returns. If you need accrual books, a reviewed month-end close or software beyond QuickBooks, compare our quote with Bench’s $699 and $999 QuickBooks plans, and ask what review each includes.

When is Bench the better fit?

  • You want bookkeeping and a business tax return from the same provider.
  • Cash-basis books are enough for how you run the business.
  • You are happy to commit to an annual plan for the discount.

When is Catching Numbers the better fit?

  • You want your books in your own QuickBooks Online, Xero, NetSuite or Sage Intacct file.
  • You need accrual books, a month-end close and a CPA signing off.
  • You want month-to-month terms.
  • You also need payroll, sales tax filing or Delaware franchise tax handled.

How do I switch from Bench?

Download your financial statements and transaction history from Bench first. We then set up or tidy your own QuickBooks Online or Xero file, bring in opening balances, reconcile from the switch date and start monthly work from the next month. Any months that need rebuilding are quoted once as a fixed fee. See our cleanup and catch-up service.

Frequently asked questions

Is Bench Accounting still in business?

Yes. Bench shut down on December 27, 2024, was acquired by Employer.com, and now sells bookkeeping and tax plans again on its website.

How much does Bench cost now?

Bench’s pricing page lists Bookkeeping Light at $199 a month, Bookkeeping at $399, Bookkeeping + Tax at $649, and QuickBooks Online plans from $399, with 20% off on annual plans, as of November 18, 2026.

Does Bench use QuickBooks?

Bench’s main bookkeeping plans run on its own platform. It also sells separate plans that work inside your QuickBooks Online file, starting at $399 a month.

Want a fixed quote to compare? Book a free consultation or call +1 (646) 450-8036.

Want this handled for you?

Book a free consultation with our CPA-led team.