Comparison card: Catching Numbers focuses on monthly books and close, 1-800Accountant on tax returns and advice

1-800Accountant is a tax-first firm: its plans run from $209 to $469 a month, billed annually, and its bookkeeping service with a dedicated bookkeeper comes in the $469 Business Complete plan alongside a business tax return. Catching Numbers is a bookkeeping and month-end close firm: plans start at $199 a month, billed month to month, in your own accounting software, and we work alongside your tax CPA rather than preparing returns. Choose 1-800Accountant if a tax return and tax advice are what you mainly need. Choose us if you need accurate monthly books, an accrual close or controller review. We compared both using each firm’s own pricing page, checked November 18, 2026. We are one of the two firms compared.

Key takeaways

  • 1-800Accountant’s plans are billed annually: Tax Advisory $209 a month, Starter $299 and Business Complete $469.
  • Full-service bookkeeping with a dedicated bookkeeper is in Business Complete, starting at 75 monthly transactions.
  • Our plans start at $199 a month, month to month, and step up to an accrual close with controller review and CPA sign-off.
  • We don’t prepare tax returns; we keep your books tax-ready and hand your tax CPA a year-end package.

How do Catching Numbers and 1-800Accountant compare on price?

Catching Numbers1-800Accountant
Entry price$199 a month: up to 2 accounts and 100 transactions, monthly profit and loss and balance sheetTax Advisory, $209 a month billed annually: dedicated accountant and tax planning, no bookkeeping listed
Bookkeeping with a dedicated bookkeeperEvery plan; early-stage companies typically $599 to $699 a monthBusiness Complete, $469 a month billed annually, starting at 75 monthly transactions
SoftwareYour own QuickBooks Online, Xero, NetSuite, Sage Intacct or AI-native ledgerIts own ClientBooks software
Month-end close with controller review$2,440 to $3,750 a month, bookkeeping included, CPA sign-offNot listed as a plan
Tax returnsNot offered; we work alongside your tax CPAOne business or personal return in Starter and Business Complete
PayrollGusto, QuickBooks Payroll or ADP, from $99 a monthOwner payroll setup in Business Complete
BillingMonth to monthBilled annually
Prices from each firm’s own pricing page, checked November 18, 2026. Confirm the current price and scope in writing before you sign.

Sources: our pricing page and 1-800Accountant’s pricing page.

What is the main difference?

1-800Accountant is organized around your tax return and tax planning, with bookkeeping added on its top plan. That suits sole owners and small LLCs whose main worry is filing on time and paying less tax.

We are organized around the monthly close. Every account is reconciled each month, statements arrive by the 7th to 10th business day, and on our month-end close and controller plans Hassaan Saleem, CPA (licensed in California) signs off before the statements go out. That matters once investors, a lender or a board read your numbers.

When is 1-800Accountant the better fit?

  • You mainly need a business tax return and year-round tax advice.
  • Your books are simple, at around 75 transactions a month.
  • Annual billing is fine for you.

When is Catching Numbers the better fit?

  • You already have a tax CPA and need clean monthly books for them.
  • You want your books in your own QuickBooks Online, Xero or NetSuite file.
  • You need accrual books, a month-end close or controller review.
  • You prefer month-to-month terms.

Frequently asked questions

How much does 1-800Accountant cost?

Its pricing page lists Tax Advisory at $209 a month, Starter at $299 and Business Complete at $469, all billed annually, as of November 18, 2026. Add-ons such as payroll tax filing are priced separately.

Does 1-800Accountant include bookkeeping?

Full-service bookkeeping with a dedicated bookkeeper is in Business Complete. Starter includes a subscription to its ClientBooks software, which you use yourself.

Can I use Catching Numbers for bookkeeping and keep my own tax CPA?

Yes. We don’t prepare returns, so every client keeps their own tax preparer. We close the books each month and hand your tax CPA a year-end package.

Want a fixed quote to compare? Book a free consultation or call +1 (646) 450-8036.

Want this handled for you?

Book a free consultation with our CPA-led team.