Comparison card: Catching Numbers works in any accounting software, Intuit Experts bookkeeping works only in QuickBooks Online

QuickBooks Live, now sold as Intuit Experts, gives you a QuickBooks-certified bookkeeper who categorizes transactions and reconciles accounts in your QuickBooks Online file. It doesn’t send invoices, pay bills, manage receivables, payables or inventory, or run payroll, and Intuit prices it by your average monthly expenses through its sales team. Catching Numbers starts at $199 a month, works in QuickBooks Online and other systems, tracks your payables and receivables, and on our close and controller plans adds accruals, bill pay, controller review and CPA sign-off. Intuit Experts suits small, simple QuickBooks Online users who handle their own bills and invoices. We suit businesses that want more of that handled, or that need a reviewed monthly close. We checked both firms’ own pages on November 18, 2026. We are one of the two firms compared.

Key takeaways

  • Intuit Experts works only in QuickBooks Online, and you can’t sign up during a QuickBooks Online trial.
  • Its bookkeepers don’t send invoices, pay bills, manage receivables, payables or inventory, or run payroll.
  • Intuit prices Full Service Bookkeeping by your average monthly expenses, reviewed every three months, plus a first-month cleanup fee; its pricing page didn’t list amounts when we checked.
  • We publish our prices, work in any accounting software and include bill pay and controller review from our Growth plan.

How do Catching Numbers and Intuit Experts compare?

Catching NumbersIntuit Experts Full Service Bookkeeping
PriceFrom $199 a month; published plans and ranges on our pricing pageQuoted by Intuit based on average monthly expenses, reassessed every three months
First monthCatch-up quoted once if needed: $150, $300 or $600 per month behind, $499 minimumA flat cleanup and setup fee if you have two or more months of data
SoftwareQuickBooks Online, Xero, NetSuite, Sage Intacct and AI-native ledgersQuickBooks Online only
Categorizing and reconcilingYesYes
Payables and receivablesTracked every month; bill pay included on our Growth planNot included; you handle invoices and bills
PayrollRun in Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll or ADP, from $99 a monthNot included; QuickBooks Payroll is extra
Month-end close with controller review$2,440 to $3,750 a month, bookkeeping included, CPA sign-offNot listed
Who may not qualifyWe work with crypto, multi-entity and other complex booksIntuit says highly complex businesses, foreign currency or crypto, or heavily mixed personal spending may not qualify
Support hoursA dedicated point of contact backed by a cross-trained teamBookkeepers work Monday to Friday, 6 AM to 6 PM Pacific
From our pricing page and Intuit’s own help and product pages, checked November 18, 2026. Confirm the current price and scope in writing before you sign.

Sources: our pricing page, Intuit’s QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping help article and its Intuit Experts page.

What is the main difference?

Intuit’s service keeps your QuickBooks Online file categorized and reconciled, and you run the rest of your finance work yourself. That works when the owner is happy to invoice, pay bills and track who owes what.

We take on more of the finance function as you grow: payables and receivables tracking, bill pay, accruals and a month-end close reviewed by a controller, with Hassaan Saleem, CPA (licensed in California) signing off on our close and controller plans. And if you move to Xero, NetSuite or Sage Intacct, we move with you.

When is Intuit Experts the better fit?

  • You use QuickBooks Online and plan to stay on it.
  • You are comfortable handling invoices, bills and payroll yourself.
  • You want to buy software and bookkeeping from one company.

When is Catching Numbers the better fit?

  • You want a published price before you talk to anyone.
  • You use Xero, NetSuite or Sage Intacct, or may switch later.
  • You want bills and payroll handled, not just categorized.
  • You have crypto, several entities or more complex books.

Frequently asked questions

Is QuickBooks Live the same as Intuit Experts?

Yes. Intuit now sells its QuickBooks Live services as Intuit Experts: Expert Assisted coaching, Expert Full Service Bookkeeping and a one-time Expert Cleanup.

How much does QuickBooks Live bookkeeping cost?

Intuit prices Full Service Bookkeeping by your average monthly expenses and reassesses it every three months, with a flat first-month fee for cleanup and setup. Its pricing page didn’t list amounts on November 18, 2026, so ask Intuit’s sales team for a quote.

Does a QuickBooks Live bookkeeper pay bills or run payroll?

No. Intuit says its bookkeepers don’t send invoices, pay bills, manage receivables, payables or inventory, or run payroll. QuickBooks Payroll is available at extra cost.

Can I keep QuickBooks Online and switch to Catching Numbers?

Yes. You keep your QuickBooks Online subscription and file, and give us accountant access. See our QuickBooks bookkeeping service.

Want a fixed quote to compare? Book a free consultation or call +1 (646) 450-8036.

Want this handled for you?

Book a free consultation with our CPA-led team.