Catching Numbers starts at $199 a month for small books and $2,440 a month for an accrual-basis month-end close signed off by a CPA, all month to month. Bookkeeper360 starts at $400 a month for bookkeeping, offers weekly books, and also sells tax returns and payroll. If you want one firm for books and taxes, Bookkeeper360 fits. If you want your books closed and reviewed in your own software, with your tax CPA kept separate, we fit. We compared both using only the prices on each firm’s own website, checked November 17, 2026. We are one of the two firms compared.
Key takeaways
- Entry price: $199 a month at Catching Numbers (up to 2 accounts and 100 transactions) against from $400 a month at Bookkeeper360.
- Both firms run payroll and file sales tax. Ours start at $99 a month each; Bookkeeper360’s start at $200 and $125. Bookkeeper360 also offers weekly bookkeeping and sells tax returns. We do not prepare tax returns and work alongside your tax CPA.
- For a month-end close with controller review, our Growth plan runs $2,440 to $3,750 a month, bookkeeping included, signed off by Hassaan Saleem, CPA.
- Catch-up work starts at $499 with us, priced per month behind, and from $1,000 at Bookkeeper360.
How do Catching Numbers and Bookkeeper360 compare on price?
The table lines up what each firm publishes. Where a firm doesn’t publish something, we say so rather than guess.
| Catching Numbers | Bookkeeper360 | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly bookkeeping | From $199 a month (up to 2 accounts and 100 transactions); early-stage companies typically $599 to $699 | From $400 a month |
| How often books are updated | Monthly | Monthly or weekly |
| Month-end close with controller review | $2,440 to $3,750 a month, bookkeeping included | Not listed as a separate plan |
| Fractional CFO | $6,350 to $8,840 a month, including bookkeeping, close and controller review | From $1,600 a month, as an add-on |
| Catch-up and cleanup | $150, $300 or $600 per month behind, by volume; $499 minimum | From $1,000 per project |
| Setup and onboarding | Quoted once as a fixed fee when needed | From $1,000 |
| Tax returns | Not offered; we hand your tax CPA a year-end package | Business returns from $1,200 a year; individual from $550 |
| Payroll, sales tax, HR | Payroll and HR support from $99 a month in Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll or ADP; sales tax registration and filing from $99 a month, with or without Avalara or TaxJar | Payroll from $200, sales tax from $125, HR from $750 a month |
| Contract | Month to month | Month to month or annual |
| Statements delivered | By the 7th to 10th business day | Not stated on its pricing page |
Sources: our pricing page and Bookkeeper360’s pricing page.
What is the main difference?
Bookkeeper360 bundles bookkeeping with tax returns, payroll, sales tax and HR, with published prices for each. Its plans include its own Bookkeeper360 software, connected to QuickBooks, Xero and Gusto.
We focus on the books themselves: reconciled every month, closed on accrual when you need it, and reviewed before the statements go out. On our month-end close and controller plans, Hassaan Saleem, CPA (licensed in California) signs off on every close. We also run payroll with employer registrations and onboarding in Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll or ADP, and register and file sales tax with or without Avalara or TaxJar, each from $99 a month. We work inside the software you already use, whether that is QuickBooks Online, Xero, NetSuite, Sage Intacct or an AI-native ledger such as Rillet or Digits, and we leave tax returns to your tax CPA.
Which costs less for a small business?
For very small books, we do. Our Basic plan is $199 a month for up to 2 bank or card accounts and 100 transactions, with a monthly profit and loss, balance sheet and year-end package. Bookkeeper360’s published starting price is $400 a month.
Once you add accounts and volume, the gap narrows: our early-stage clients typically pay $599 to $699 a month. If you would also buy tax returns from the same firm, add Bookkeeper360’s tax prices to the comparison, since we don’t prepare returns.
Which is better for a month-end close or controller support?
If investors, a board or a lender read your numbers every month, you need more than categorized transactions. Our month-end close includes accruals, prepaids, deferred revenue, a balance sheet review and statements by the 7th to 10th business day. Controller review starts on our Growth plan at $2,440 a month, bookkeeping included. See outsourced controller services.
Bookkeeper360 offers cash or accrual books and a fractional CFO from $1,600 a month, but its pricing page doesn’t list a controller-level close as its own plan. Ask them how the close is reviewed and when statements arrive.
When is Bookkeeper360 the better fit?
- You want tax returns prepared by the same firm that keeps your books.
- You want books updated weekly rather than monthly.
- You want a full HR service that goes beyond payroll administration.
When is Catching Numbers the better fit?
- Your books are small and you want to start at $199 a month.
- You need an accrual close with controller review and a CPA signing off each month.
- You want payroll and sales tax handled by the same team that closes your books, from $99 a month each.
- You use NetSuite, Sage Intacct or an AI-native ledger, or want to stay in your own QuickBooks or Xero file.
- You are behind and want catch-up priced per month, from $499.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Bookkeeper360 cost?
Bookkeeper360’s pricing page lists bookkeeping from $400 a month, catch-up and setup from $1,000 each, and a fractional CFO from $1,600 a month, as of November 17, 2026. Tax, payroll, sales tax and HR are priced separately.
Can I switch from Bookkeeper360 to Catching Numbers during the year?
Yes. We review your current file, agree the close calendar and start from the next month. If earlier months need fixing, we quote that once as a fixed fee before monthly work begins.
Do I keep my own QuickBooks or Xero file with Catching Numbers?
Yes. We work inside your own accounting software through the accountant access you give us, so the file and its history stay yours.
Want a fixed quote to compare? Book a free consultation or call +1 (646) 450-8036.