Pilot starts lower, at $99 a month for AI-assisted cash books, and its Core plan with a US-based bookkeeper starts at $299 a month billed annually. Catching Numbers starts at $199 a month, billed month to month, and works inside your own accounting software. Pilot fits venture-backed startups that want bookkeeping, tax and CFO plans from one provider on annual billing. We fit companies that want to keep their own QuickBooks, Xero or NetSuite file, need a monthly close signed off by a CPA, or don’t want an annual commitment. We compared both using only each firm’s own pricing page, checked November 17, 2026. We are one of the two firms compared.
Key takeaways
- Pilot Essentials is $99 a month for cash books built from bank and card data; Pilot Core starts at $299 a month billed annually, at $9,000 in monthly expenses.
- Pilot delivers Core reports on the 10th business day and Custom reports on the 6th; we deliver by the 7th to 10th business day.
- Pilot lists keeping your existing QuickBooks account as a Custom-plan option. We always work in your own software.
- Pilot sells tax returns from $1,000 a year with its bookkeeping. We don’t prepare returns and work alongside your tax CPA.
How do Catching Numbers and Pilot compare on price?
Pilot prices Core by monthly expenses and bills it annually. We price by transactions, accounts and the level of review, billed monthly.
| Catching Numbers | Pilot | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry plan | Basic, from $199 a month: up to 2 accounts and 100 transactions, monthly profit and loss and balance sheet | Essentials, $99 a month: up to $100,000 in monthly expenses, cash basis, AI answers and in-app messaging support |
| Plan with a dedicated bookkeeper | Every plan; early-stage companies typically $599 to $699 a month | Core, starts at $299 a month billed annually, at $9,000 in monthly expenses; US-based bookkeeper |
| Cash or accrual | Accrual-basis close from our Growth plan | Cash or accrual on Core |
| Review of the books | Controller review on our Growth plan, $2,440 to $3,750 a month, with CPA sign-off | Core: your US-based bookkeeper reviews the books; Custom quoted by sales |
| Statements delivered | By the 7th to 10th business day | Core: 10th business day; Custom: 6th business day |
| Your own software | Always: QuickBooks Online, Xero, NetSuite, Sage Intacct, Rillet, Digits and others | Keeping your existing QuickBooks account is listed under Custom |
| Fractional CFO | $6,350 to $8,840 a month, including bookkeeping, close and controller review | $1,750, $3,150 or $5,250 a month, billed annually |
| Tax returns | Not offered; we hand your tax CPA a year-end package | From $1,000 a year (single-member LLC), $2,000 (partnership or S corp), $2,450 (C corp), bought with Pilot bookkeeping |
| Billing | Month to month | Core, tax and CFO plans billed annually |
Sources: our pricing page and Pilot’s pricing page.
What is the main difference?
Pilot is a startup-focused provider that combines software, bookkeepers, tax and CFO services, with annual plans and a tiered price that rises with your spending. Its entry plan leans on AI and messaging support; a US-based bookkeeper starts with Core.
We are a CPA-led firm that runs your books in the system you already own, on monthly terms. Your controller reviews the close, and on our month-end close and controller plans, Hassaan Saleem, CPA (licensed in California) signs off before the statements go out.
Which costs less?
For a very small, cash-basis business that is comfortable with AI-assisted books, Pilot Essentials at $99 a month costs less. Once you want a named bookkeeper, compare our $199 Basic plan, or our typical $599 to $699 for early-stage companies, with Pilot Core from $299 a month paid annually. Remember that Core’s price steps up as your monthly expenses grow.
Which is better for a venture-backed startup?
Both work with startups. Pilot’s Custom plan promises reports by the 6th business day. We suit founders who want accrual books and a CPA-reviewed close without an annual contract, or who already run on NetSuite or an AI-native ledger. See startup accounting and SaaS accounting.
When is Pilot the better fit?
- You want the lowest entry price and are fine with AI-assisted cash books.
- You want bookkeeping, tax returns and CFO support from one provider.
- Annual billing is not a concern.
When is Catching Numbers the better fit?
- You want to keep your own QuickBooks, Xero, NetSuite or Sage Intacct file from day one.
- You want a monthly close signed off by a CPA.
- You prefer month-to-month terms.
- You want your tax CPA kept separate from your bookkeeper.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Pilot bookkeeping cost?
Pilot’s pricing page lists Essentials at $99 a month and Core starting at $299 a month billed annually at $9,000 in monthly expenses, with Custom quoted by sales, as of November 17, 2026. Core’s price rises with your monthly expenses.
Does Pilot use my QuickBooks account?
Pilot lists keeping your existing QuickBooks account and historical data as part of its Custom plan. Ask which software your plan uses before you sign. We always work in your own accounting software.
Can I switch from Pilot to Catching Numbers?
Yes. We review your books and history, agree a close calendar and start from the next month. If your books need to move into your own QuickBooks or Xero file, we quote that setup once as a fixed fee.
Want a fixed quote to compare? Book a free consultation or call +1 (646) 450-8036.